The Egotistical Priest

An irreverent and opinionated discussion of the many classes
in the World of Warcraft gaming universe.

More Tanking Tidbits

by Aensu
author is Aensu

At the risk of repeating myself, I’m going to make a post about tanking. Shocking, I know. But alot of tanking is repetition. No one can really know every detail of any particular instance their first time through, or even their first 10 times through, no matter how much they read. You have to get out there and do it. And once you figure out a way to handle a difficult pull or boss fight, you have to do it again, and again, to make sure it wasn’t a fluke. Then you have to remember all those little strategies. Put them all together and you have a smooth run that’ll make people say,”Hey, that was a smooth run!”

I’ve often been asked the question “Can you teach me how to tank?”. The short answer is: Nope. You simply can’t instill in a novice with an explanation, no matter how lengthy, what takes hundreds and hundreds of hours of experience across multiple venues and from multiple viewpoints to get. Hell, I’ve learned as much about tanking from playing non-tanks in other games as I have from playing the tanking classes in WoW. The slightly not as short answer is: Only you can teach you how to tank.

But, being the pretentious bastard I am, I try to teach them anyway.

So, at the risk of repeating myself, here’s some more “Tanking Tidbits” that have nothing to do with numbers or game mechanics, and everything to do with the player, where it all begins.


1) Get your fingers off those damned arrow keys.

I can’t tell you how painful it is to watch a tank slowly shuffle-shuffle-shuffle to the left or run in a semicircle, attempting to do a 180 to chase after the mob they just lost to healing aggro or a ranged dps that nuked the wrong target.

This is what we call a “key turner”, and whether they are using the arrow keys or WASD or anything else, their slow reactions have caused thousands of wipes and healer deaths. Seriously, no matter how quickly you react, if the keyboard is your only means of locomotion, you are too slow.

Use the mouse for turning. Do it. Play some FPS games to help you get used to it if you have to. If you cannot or will not use the mouse for movement, play a caster or something, you do your comrades a disservice if you insist on being a tank while crippling yourself.

2) Stop clicking. Just stop.

Make macros. You should have a macro for every single ability you use or even think you might use, including potions and trinkets and healthstones and everything else. Even if you have the fastest hand in the west and never have trouble locating your cursor in the middle of a chaotic fight with brightly colored spell effects firing off everywhere while watching your threat meters and maintaining your rotation and situational awareness, you’re still too slow.

Some will swear up and down with much gnashing of teeth and rending of garments that being a clicker is ok and just as fast. It’s ok for some classes, at least in pve, but it’s not ok for tanks, ever. Even the uninitiated can see the difference in your performance, usually in their repair bill. They can continue to click if they wish, and I will strafe past them at full speed towards my group while spin jumping quarter circles to spend most of the trip facing the pull to maintain avoidance and avoid getting dazed while still building threat and managing to target and intercept that add bearing down on the healer from the other side of the group, all in less time than it takes to sing “I can do anything you can do betteeer!”

3) Take your Ritalin and pay attention.

You should not only be aware of the location of your team mates and the mobs you just pulled at all times, but you should also be aware of possible dangers that have yet to manifest. Since you’re not using your mouse to click your abilities, once you’ve positioned your pull comfortably, you are free to rotate the camera around and observe your surroundings. If that patrol you were waiting for comes earlier than you’d expected, you want to know about it. If one of your ranged dps is backing into the aggro range of a group you were trying to skip, you want to know about it. You can’t know about it if you didn’t see it, at least not fast enough for it to count.

If your group wipes to adds that you could’ve tanked had you seen them aggro sooner, it’s your fault. Even if someone else pulled them. It’d be nice if they’d been paying more attention and hadn’t pulled them in the first place, but it’s still your fault.

4) Learn to type.

How someone can spend any significant amount of time using a computer, much less playing a social game where text is the primary means of communication, without becoming a touch typist is beyond me. Still, there are people out there who are slowly hunt and pecking their way to victory.

If this is you and you want to tank, please, learn to type. There are a number of free games and tutor programs that will help you.

“But the game has built in voice chat, I don’t need to type to communicate anymore!”, he cried indignantly.

Irrelevant.

If you have to look at your keyboard to type, then you have to look at your keyboard to use macros with any accuracy. If you’re looking at your keyboard, then you’re not looking at your screen, and your attention is divided between keeping your group safe and trying to find the right keys.

There you have it, four things that would go a long way towards turning some of the worst meatshields I’ve ever seen into real tanks. Maybe you’re special, and you can make clicking and key turning work for you, but no matter how fast you are at it, no matter how you justify it, you will still be slower, less precise, and less focused than you would be if you didn’t. PvP isn’t the only facet of the game where every second counts. That one second you saved, getting that taunt off an instant earlier than you otherwise would have, can and often will save the group from a death or a wipe. And those you tank for will come to appreciate that.

9 Responses to “More Tanking Tidbits”

  1. joshua Says:

    The learn to type issue really hits home. Closely related to READ. How many times do we have to type out some important message, only to find out the key people who should be reading simply are not. Drives me nuts.

  2. Seriouscat Says:

    I have been reading this site forevar it seems like, and I love Ego’s posts. Everything I have ever wanted to know about the priest class and more, which has been very helpful to me as a tank.

    But I really can’t say I enjoy your posts here. Ego is charmingly egotistical. You are abrasively so. I am very sad that I cannot filter your posts from my feedreader.

  3. DefensiveCat Says:

    The irony, of course, is that Ego isn’t really egotistical. Charming? Absolutely. But not egotistical. Sorry to blow your cover there, Vonya ;)

  4. Sonvar Says:

    I don’t know about macros because if an item requires only one click or button push like a pot then it shouldn’t need a macro. Now if its an assist or focus macro I can understand that one a bit more.

    Your point about using the mouse for movement is valid and I need to get more used to it at least for becoming a bear tank.

    @Seriouscat
    A bit harsh yourself don’t you think?

  5. Sweetpetal Says:

    I’ve tried tanking. Can’t do it.

    I’ve healed Kara more times than I can remember, so I leveled up a lovely Druid to 70. Read about the correct gear, talents, tanking techniques. I had the theory down pat. I knew my stuff. Practised pulling with moonfire, with faerie fire, with who-knows-bloody-what fire, practised swiping, lacerating, taunting. You name it, I practised it.

    But then it came to tanking. You know, real live tanking, with other players. I couldn’t do it. I got confused, we wiped, everybody abused me (with reason), I tried again and again and again. Couldn’t do it. Now I hate tanking. I could (theoretically) tank Kara, given my gear. But I never will, that’s for sure.

    I think that tanks are born, not made.

  6. Esoth Says:

    Keyboard turning w/strafing is perfectly adequate, unless you have to turn more than more than about (rough guess here) 60 degrees. In that case, nothing beats good mouse turning. This also means it’s much more pertinent to melee classes than healers or ranged. On my hunter, in pve, I normally only have to turn this much when I’m kiting/jump-shotting or, for instance, Solarian decides to target me with Wrath and I need to get the hell out of there. So it seems obvious that turning this way is appropriate for a tank, but if you are losing mobs due to HEALING aggro, you need to l2tank, or swallow your pride and realize that something needs to be CC’d.

  7. Artreeo Says:

    Aside from an “omg we’re all gonna die.” macro, that does an AOE taunt (Challenging Roar/Challenging Shout) then pops a trinket followed by Fenzied Regen/Shield Wall & then tells everyone, ‘Please heal me, extra damage is coming.’ -

    - I’m curious what other macros you would recommend for tanking?

  8. Aensu Says:

    @Sonvar

    I didn’t use to think it was needed either, but I found myself dying with 1 or more of my emergency buttons unused more often than not and wondering “what if”. After binding them to accessible keys so that there was less delay between deciding it was needed and actually using it, I noticed an immediate improvement to my survival rate in close calls. (note that I am also a tard and may say “macro” when I mean “keybind” on a regular basis)

    @Artreeo

    It depends as much on your current setup and what’s most efficient in that context as anything else. For example, I switch stances with A, S, D, and use macros so those keys serve secondary, stance specific purposes if I’m already in that stance. A = mocking blow, S = intervene, D = berserker rage. My paladin has a macro to cast Blessing of Protection on my target if it is friendly, my target’s target if my target is hostile, and a /cancelaura Blessing of Protection with a second press for those times I regain aggro just as I hit the macro and accidentally BoP myself :D

    There’s an extensive library of macros you can copy/paste or use as a reference for syntax to make your own on WoWWiki, check it out: http://www.wowwiki.com/Macros

  9. Robur Says:

    @Sweetpetal
    Did I get that right: You leveled a druid to 70 and started to tank with him at that level? And possibly in Kara, too?
    If the answer to the first question is yes, then, in my opinion, you made a common mistake. You could have learned a lot about tanking with that druid, if you had played him as a tank right away, tanking through all (or most) of the 5 man instances available.
    I should take back the word “mistake”, perhaps. I suppose you can start learning to play a new role at any character level. But you should make sure to do a _lot_ of training.
    If, with your druid, tanking in, say, Mana Tombs seems too hard, perhaps try tanking with non-elite mobs outside of instances.
    Just suggestions, of course.

Leave a Reply